Navigating The Challenges Of Problem Employees

Robin RobinsMSP Marketing

Leadership is not a popularity contest. It’s a delicate balance between being fair and maintaining firmness, a principle I’ve adhered to throughout my career. The quest for likability can undermine a leader’s effectiveness, as it often leads to compromise on standards and accountability. This blog post draws on my personal experiences and observations, offering actionable insights into managing problem employees effectively.

Leadership Philosophy: A Tough But Fair Approach

Leadership demands a tough but fair approach. The need to be liked can be a manager’s downfall, leading to indecisiveness and a lack of respect from the team. Through my journey, I’ve learned that respect is far more valuable than likability. It’s about setting clear expectations, holding people accountable, and not shying away from the hard decisions. True leadership means making choices that benefit the company and the team as a whole, even if they’re unpopular in the moment.

The Strategy Of Constant Recruitment

I’ve always believed in the power of constant recruitment. This practice isn’t about replacing your team members; it’s about maintaining a high standard and having the leverage to address performance issues without desperation. By always being in a hiring mode, you ensure a pipeline of potential talent, which allows you to make more strategic decisions about your workforce.

Dealing With Underperformance

Dealing with underperformance is perhaps one of the most challenging aspects of leadership. The key is not to tolerate poor behavior or subpar work. This stance might seem harsh, but it’s necessary for maintaining a high-performing team. I advocate for direct communication, setting clear performance metrics, and, when necessary, making the tough decision to let someone go for the greater good of the team.

Cultivating A Motivating Culture

A motivating work culture is crucial for attracting and retaining top talent. However, perks and benefits should not be the sole focus. Instead, foster an environment that rewards achievement and hard work. This approach attracts individuals who are driven by success and personal growth, rather than just the next office perk.

The Balance Of Trust And Generosity

Trust and generosity are important, but they have their limits. My experience has taught me to be cautious of extending trust blindly and to be mindful of the generosity I offer. Support your team, but ensure there are boundaries and expectations regarding performance and professional behavior.

Leading By Example

Leadership is not just about directing; it’s about doing. Setting clear goals, leading by example, and holding yourself accountable are essential practices. I’ve found regular, constructive feedback and a transparent performance evaluation system to be incredibly effective in maintaining high standards and accountability within my team.


In conclusion, managing problem employees requires a blend of strong leadership, continuous recruitment, clear communication, and a performance-oriented culture. As MSP owners, we must strive for respect over popularity, make tough decisions when necessary, and lead by example. I hope my insights encourage you to reflect on your leadership approach and inspire you to foster a work environment that values performance, accountability, and continuous improvement.

Get more MSP growth strategies from Robin Robins, Dr. Jordan Peterson, Mike Michalowicz, and many more at this year’s IT Marketing Boot Camp.